CIRCULAR BUSINESS IS HOT.
AND THAT’S AN UNDERSTATEMENT.
Type the term into your search engine of choice and you’ll get more than 776,000 results. So there’s a lot being written, debated and philosophised about the subject. And rightly so, because caring for our planet is a universal concern, a matter of survival for current and future generations.
Debate is a good thing, then, as long as it doesn’t get bogged down in endless intellectual discussions that lead almost nowhere. Did you know, for example, that no fewer than 114 scientific definitions are in circulation to capture the concept of circular business? Great for scientists, but our style is a little different.
We’d rather roll up our sleeves, put our own house in order and look at what we can do ourselves.
So at the 2021 edition of the Belgian Pork Academy, we once again brought together scientists, producers, professionals, pig farmers and retailers to explore together how we can make our fine pig sector even more sustainable.
In the spotlight: Steven De Meester
PROFILE
- Bioscience engineer
- Prof. Dr., Associate Professor, Department of Green Chemistry and Technology (Faculty of Bioscience Engineering), Ghent University
- His research includes the recycling of organic and plastic waste
“ABOVE ALL, STAY MASTER OF YOUR OWN DEBATE.”
Professor Steven De Meester is pleased to note that the pig sector is actually already very circular. In his view, there’s less and less room for improvement. So it’s time for a different, fundamental debate: how do you develop, as an entire sector, a new economic model for customers who want to eat less meat and more sustainable meat?
For several years, Professor De Meester has been researching high-quality recycling of plastic and organic waste. That puts him at the heart of the very broad circularity debate. “We constantly talk about recycling and the circular economy, but there’s actually no single, clear definition of either. Alongside the many well-meaning initiatives, we’ll therefore need more of a common language to develop effective policy.”
“MANY CONSUMERS ONLY LOOK AT THE AMOUNT OF PLASTIC WE USE, WHEREAS YOU ALSO HAVE TO LOOK AT EVERYTHING THAT COMES BEFORE IT.”
For De Meester, the essence of a circular economy is becoming as independent as possible from primary raw materials. “Europe actually has very few raw materials of its own. In the food industry, for example, we import soybeans from Brazil. In that context, circularity means keeping those raw materials here, whether they’re critical metals or elements like nitrogen and phosphorus, and using and reusing them as much as possible.”
At the moment, circularity in food is often reduced to the packaging story. “Many consumers only look at the amount of plastic we use, whereas you also have to look at everything that comes before it. Once you look at it through that lens, you’ll see the focus isn’t always in the right place. Plastic bags, for instance, are currently the big villain in supermarkets, but did you know you have to use your cotton shopping bag 173 times before its ecological footprint is lower than that of the plastic bag? The impact of how meat is produced is many times greater than that of packaging. So if you analyse the system more broadly, you see that any loss of meat is many times worse than the impact of the packaging. Which of course doesn’t mean we shouldn’t invest in circular packaging…”
The professor also always distinguishes between production on the one hand and consumption on the other when it comes to circularity. “The pork sector is in a specific situation, because there’s little you can do on the consumption side. Food is truly consumed, and that can only happen once. That’s not the same as systems like Cambio car sharing, for example, where you can ‘consume’ the same product several times. In that sense, it’s harder to make food consumption circular than in other sectors such as electronics or textiles.
On the production side, I see that the pig sector has already made a great deal of effort on circularity. Pigs already eat a lot of side streams (the term ‘waste’ is even less relevant here). We’re also very efficient at using feed to produce meat, we’re increasingly optimising our energy use, and the feed industry is taking serious steps forward too. That’s simply the downside of a sector that’s actively working on the issue: it becomes harder and harder to make significant progress.”
De Meester doubts whether additional efforts can still turn around the sometimes negative perception of (pig) meat in times of climate debate. In his view, we need to ask ourselves whether it’s time for a different debate.
…
“MAKE AN OFFER SOCIETY CAN’T REFUSE.
REVALUE YOUR PRODUCT, WITH A FAIR PRICE, FOR THE FARMER TOO.”
“Perhaps the time has come for the sector to think about the really long term and look at how it will organise itself over the next twenty years. What meat will consumers still eat? And what’s a profitable business model for producing that meat? Prices are under pressure, consumers are increasingly suspicious of meat, there are more and more flexitarians, production requirements are rising and in the long run less meat will be eaten. What answer does the sector have ready for that?
For many, that debate still feels like a distant concern. The sector can focus on exports, but growth there will also come to an end at some point. The car industry never thought the electric car would break through either. Yet all it takes is one game changer like Tesla to fundamentally change the market. Now everyone assumes that the whole world, including countries like China, will be driving fully electric within a few years. You see it in other sectors too: soon we’ll be heating all our homes with heat pumps instead of gas, which was once considered so sustainable.”
According to De Meester, it’s time for the sector to develop a new economic model itself. “They’d do better to keep control of this themselves, so they can propose the solutions they want. I’d like to make a heartfelt appeal: anticipate, and see this transition as an opportunity.
To put it naively: what production and consumption system would make you happy? Will ‘a lot’ and ‘cheap’ still be the key words in 20 years’ time, in a society that has been changed by sustainability goals? Or will it be ‘less’ and ‘more sustainable’? Make an offer society can’t refuse. Revalue your product, with a fair price, for the farmer too.
It’s better not to leave this kind of debate to politicians. Just look at the plastics sector: a very strong sector, but in the debates they waited too long to take control of the ‘sustainable’ or ‘circular’ agenda themselves. The result: now we all have to drink through dreary bamboo straws, a solution nobody is happy with…”
STEVEN ON THE BELGIAN PORK ACADEMY:
Professor Steven De Meester was taken with the Belgian Pork Academy: “It was nice to see people take a step back to have a different kind of debate. You need to be able to think outside the box. Agriculture always tends to just keep going; the farmer ploughed on. Right now everyone is still watching each other, but initiatives like this do bring the different players together. And in time, they’ll undoubtedly lead to valuable solutions.”